Cake Cheating

Personally, I like pie. Lemon Meringue Pie. Apple Pie. Berry Pie. Cheesecake. Yeah, that’s a pie more than a cake in my book. And since I’m a food snob, I’ve been making pies from scratch for a long time, since I was 10 and my dad conned me into it.

But, awhile ago I found out that my husband and children prefer cake. Humph! I was a little putoff — for several reasons.

1. I think pie’s better. And since I’m a know-it-all, bossy-big-sister, everyone should agree with me.
2. I bake good pies. (I think that goes along with the second half of #1)
3. I’m not that good at cake baking. I almost told them they were never eating cake again when my first attempts at a from-scratch layer cake ended like brick saucers.

Then, I put my food snob tendencies aside and tried a boxed cake mix. And it wasn’t bad. Yes, I know, it’s not as good for you as baked from scratch, but for birthdays when things are crazy and children are hyper, they are the way to go. Plus, I found this great cookbook called The Cake Mix Doctor. It lists tons of recipes that take a boxed mix and make it more. As if ease and convenience weren’t enough, if you combine sales and coupons, you can get a cake mix for a few quarters.

Two thumbs up for the cake fans in my house!

For more kitchen tips, visit Tammy’s Recipes every Tuesday.
For more cake-ish fun, come back on Thursday for The Birthday Cake Round Up.

Would you rather subscribe by RSS?
Read Newer Post
Read Older Post


  1. I have a secret to share. Boxed cake is normally moister. My friend made me a cake from scratch for my birthday. Being a self-professed food snob, she said that she wouldn’t “stoop” to use a boxed cake mix. Well, her cake was a bit dry :-/.

    Though, boxed cake mix has the evil “partially hydrogenated soybean oil” in it.

  2. JessieLeigh says:

    You already know this is one of the only things we don’t have in common… I’m not a pie person! :)

    I’ve made cakes both ways and have come to the conclusion that I can make good homemade cupcakes, but my homemade cakes kind of flop. So to the box I go! I’ve yet to hear a complaint…

  3. I’m all about a boxed cake mix. I doctor it up according to the recipe. The VERY BEST wedding cake I’ve EVER had starts with a box… hmmm. ;-)

  4. YEA, thank you. I can’t believe I won. I hadnt been over in a little bit, as school kept me pretty busy last week. So thanks for letting me know.

  5. Raggedy Girl says:

    I think all those women of long ago would have used a cake mix if there had been one. I too like to play with them. But I am with you… pie rules!
    Happy Tuesday from
    Roberta Anne

  6. Katie @ Heart Gone Walking says:

    I’ve really enjoyed all these cakes posts as someone who can’t bake or decorate cakes. At all.

    This was my first attempt at a two-layered cake. Needless to say, it didn’t turn out.

  7. You are WAY too good of a cook to use a box! I like you strive to feed my kids as healthy as possible and with all the persevatives, trans fats, food coloring and high fructose corn syrups box mixes are out of the question at our house.

    Try The Joys of Baking website! There are a lot of cake recipes (the Banana Chocolate Cake is a personal favorite) and pie recipes ;) as well. I think it would really help in your quest to make heathier cake for your family!

    Good Luck!!


  1. [...] didn’t celebrate any birthdays, but I did decorate a cake to keep you company. And since they like cake more than pie, I didn’t hear any [...]

  2. [...] a mom who likes to make cool cakes for her kids. When they told me that I couldn’t make them pie for their birthdays, I had to get [...]

  3. [...] even though I’m really big on baking from scratch, when it comes to cakes, I generally cheat. Yes, I looove boxed cake mixes. Go ahead and judge me. So, when I heard about the latest sale at [...]

  4. [...] still use boxed cake mixes. But, baby steps, baby [...]

  5. [...] celebrate four birthdays in three weeks’ time which means lots of cake! But, remember? They like cake better than pie around here. So, it’s all [...]

  6. [...] like to use a boxed cake mix, but you can use your favorite recipe. I used a single layer round since I wasn’t feeding a [...]

  7. [...] my family doesn’t love pie, it’s been a long time since I’ve made one. I guess you could say this used to be my [...]

  8. [...] made and decorated quite a few cakes in my time. I still use a mix because I find that everyone likes it so much better. And how healthy do you want a cake to be, [...]

Thanks so much for participating in this conversation about "a mom's life."

This is a place where moms can be themselves. Remember that each mother's path looks a little different. Please keep your comments respectful and kind. Reasonable minds will disagree in a nice way.

So let's talk about it, using "our big girl words."

Share Your Thoughts