How to Make 12 Different Christmas Cookies Without Going Insane (An Ultimate Recipe Swap)

Ultimate Recipe Swap

I love the tradition of Christmas Cookies. There are so many memories attached to cookies. Whether it was baking them with your gramma or mom or decorating them with your siblings, my guess is that most of us have some sweet recollection of cookies, especially at the holidays.

And I bet you can’t stop at just one.

I mean, really, think of all the cookies that are special to Christmas that you rarely enjoy the other 11 months out of the year. Wouldn’t it be fun to have them all congregated in one place?

I think so. Watch!

I love the idea of serving a wide variety of Christmas cookies at one time. This can be a tricky feat. Who wants to spend three days baking? Or worse, who has the willpower to resist eating said “wide variety of Christmas cookies at one time?”

This is where your freezer comes in to make things a little easier for you at the holidays!

There are several techniques to making cookies and freezing them that can help you this month. And you can have 12 different kinds of cookies and not go insane.

Here’s how:

Use a food processor or stand mixer.

By using a small kitchen appliance like a food processor or stand mixer, you can quickly prepare many batches of dough in quick succession. In fact, start with the plainest cookie dough (like sugar) and work your way up to the chocolate and then the peppermint. Since these cookies most likely all start with butter, sugar, and flour, you don’t need to wash the bowl between each batch.

Yes, really. Provided that you’re mixing things in a short amount of time, this should not be a problem. If you’d rather wash the bowl in between batches, feel free to do so. You’ll still save time by using a machine and by mixing many batches of dough in quick succession.

As each batch of dough is prepared, wrap it in plastic wrap or place it in an airtight container and stash it in the refrigerator. By performing all your like tasks together, mixing, forming, and baking, you’ll save time and energy.

Make and freeze bulk cookie dough.

Once you have your doughs prepared, you can just freeze them as is until a day that you want fresh baked cookies. Just thaw the dough overnight and it should be ready to roll and bake the next day.

If you freeze the dough in round logs, you won’t have to wait more than an hour. You can have slice and bake cookies in a jiffy.

Make and freeze individual cookie dough balls.

Another option is to freeze the dough in “ready to bake” dough balls. Check out Katie’s tutorial for detailed instructions.

Bake and freeze the cookies.

This is probably the easiest and my favorite way. I prepare the doughs and then roll and bake in quick succession. I don’t do all 12 at once, more like 3 or 4 kinds at a session. I layer cooled cookies between layers of waxed paper in large, airtight containers. Baked cookies should be good in the freezer for at least a month if wrapped properly.

When I want to assemble cookie trays, I pull my boxes out of the freezer and place a few cookies on each tray. They thaw in a matter of minutes, and I have a great gift or dessert without a lot of last minute prep work. This also gives you a breather and a chance to spend some time making your presentation a little prettier.

Tackle your baking in stages.

Unless you want to bake all day, consider three or four baking sessions. One year, I just made a plan to do a batch of cookies every day for a couple weeks. It didn’t take more than an hour each day, and since I was stashing it all in the fridge right away, I built a sweet little stockpile.

Include the family.

It goes without saying that kids love to help bake cookies. But, you can also get their input about which cookies to bake. I quizzed my kids over the last couple weeks before we tackled our cookie baking over this long holiday weekend.

They had so much fun. And while things were a mess — and I had some hilarious flops (more on that later) — it was a great time. And our freezer is full of cookies to last us at least a week or two a month.

12 Days of Christmas Cookies

Wondering what’s going on our cookie platters this year? I’ll be sharing our favorite recipes and some new tweaks in the coming weeks on both LifeasMOM and GoodCheapEats. So grab your cup of coffee or tea and let’s eat some cookies!

  1. Lemon-Ginger Bars – I took an old favorite and added crystallized ginger.
  2. Double Chocolate Magic Bars — 7 Layer Bars with Oreos!
  3. Chocolate Minty Melts
  4. Chocolate Chocolate Chip Biscotti
  5. Oatmeal Thumbprint Cookies with Cassis Jam
  6. Super Simple Fudge
  7. Snowball Cookies
  8. Jesus Sugar Cookies — & our Nativity Bake Set
  9. Oatmeal Cranberry Jumbles
  10. Peppermint Brownie Bites
  11. Gramma John’s Blue Ribbon Chocolate Chip Cookies
  12. Simply Sprinkled Sugar Cookie Cutouts

What are YOUR favorite cookie recipes?

Share them with us for today’s Christmas cookie exchange.

Curious about freezer cooking? Consider purchasing my cookbook, Not Your Mother’s Make-Ahead and Freeze Cookbook from Amazon, Barnes and Noble, or your local bookstore. It’s chock full with over 200 freezer-friendly recipes, planning pages, shopping lists, cooking plans, and basic and advanced how-to’s to making freezer cooking work for any home, family, and lifestyle.

Would you rather subscribe by RSS?
Read Newer Post
Read Older Post

Comments

  1. I’ve never understood the whole, making several different kinds of cookie thing. I stick to one at a time! Great tips though for the inspired! Thanks!

  2. Oh man, I want cookies NOW!

    I shared my recipe for sufganiyot – Israeli jelly donuts eaten traditionally on Hanukkah. Not exactly a cookie, but I hope it’s close enough ;).

  3. Hey Jess, check out the “Sablés sans oeufs”. I thought that they could substitute for Sugar Cookies for FishChick since they don’t have eggs. They taste a bit similar. They are soft out of the oven, get crunchy as they cool, but get soft again when they’re stored.

    • Jessica Fisher says:

      @Janel, cute pic of Lu! We made about half the cookies without egg, but we’ll have to try this one next time since Mom’s recipe does have an egg, I think.

  4. Ack, I don’t have a food processor or a stand mixer. I guess I’ll pick out a cookie a week to tackle with Peanut Butter and Jelly and maybe enlist my teen daughter for a ta da type cookie some time before the holidays(she loves to bake so while she’ll appreaciate the easy peasy stuff I think she also would like something more “grown up.”)

    4 batches of cookies should give us enough variety. If I start on Friday and challenge myself to making a batch each Friday we should be good to go.

    By the way for those who celebrate Hanukkah, Happy Hanukkah(their celebration just started)!

  5. I am making plans for my big cookie baking session. I should have started it earlier, but this season really did sneak up on me.

    Thanks for the link-up.

  6. I have just started the baking-go-round – yesterday I did about 10 dozen chocolate crinkle dough balls – half are flash freezing – when I’m more awake I’ll bag them and freeze the half that spent the night in the fridge.
    Today is molasses cookies I think . . . I love my freezers!

  7. Fantastic tips! I really enjoyed your post. And those lemon ginger bars looks so yummy – I’ve bookmarked the recipe. Thank you for hosting.

  8. I just made Chocolate Bon-Bon’s with my Mother-in-Law over Thanksgiving! They are so addicting! I can’t wait to make more and they are so easy! They also don’t have eggs in them.

  9. That’s really the only way to do it!

  10. Ha! I had to laugh when I looked at your photos — you and I have the SAME food processor AND mixer :)))

  11. My favorite would have to be chocolate chip cookies.
    We are planning a girls day of cooking making.. (my mom, sister and myself) I am sure the kids will be in there too!
    I really want to try my hand at rugula (sp?) My grandma tried to make it for me once, and it ended up in the garbage! (and this is a lady that at any time when i was younger could go into her house and she would have at all time at least 6 different types of cookies!)

  12. are you planning to share your recipe for the choc kiss cookies? The standard one is with the pbutter cookie but with nut allergies, I’d love an alternative!

  13. I love sharing cookie/square recipes! The #1 cookie/bar in our house are Kokanee circles. You use a cookie cutter to make them into nice cookie size treats. This recipe is made with whole natural ingredients.

  14. Every time I think about Christmas cookies I have memories of the year I made several different cookies in one day and I only had one cookie sheet. What I was thinking I’ll never know – I must have had some insane ambition in those days but I’ll never do that again. Thanks for hosting. Lots of yummy ideas.

  15. So easy and so good!
    Coconut Macaroons (Ina Garten Recipe)
    (Oven @ 325)
    14 oz Sweetened shredded coconut
    14 oz Sweetened condensed milk
    1t. vanilla
    2 xlg or 3 regular egg whites. Must be left out and at room temperature before using.
    1/4 t. salt
    Mix coconut and can of milk. Add vanilla and mix.
    Whip egg whites and salt unitl firm peaks are formed.
    Fold egg whites into coconut mixture.
    Put parchment on sheet pans (must have parchment as they are sticky even on a no-stick pan).
    Scoop with small ice cream scoop or use two teaspoons.
    Bake 25-30 minutes until golden (watch carefully the first time you make them as every oven is different).

  16. You have quite a round-up here. I can have some fun. I love baking. Thanks for doing this.

  17. Thanks for letting us link up. I am so excited about the cookie ideas! I need to get our caroling gifts ready!!!

  18. Chocolate chip, of course! Also, Rice Krispie treats, my husband’s favorite Christmas cookies (his grandma’s recipe), and does fudge count? Because that looks like fudge on the platter. If so, peanut butter fudge for the hubs, and chocolate for me!

    • Jessica Fisher says:

      @Amy, yes, it’s a new-to-us fudge recipe. I used to always make fudge with marshmellow creme, but that has egg whites in it.

  19. Ooooh I can’t wait to look around at these recipes – thanks for hosting this!

    You know what, it never occured to me that I don’t *have* to wash the bowl after every batch! Genius! Every time saving step counts – I’ll be sure to keep it in mind when I marathon bake this weekend!

  20. Thanks to all for sharing such great recipes. This is the first year I feel inspired to do our own cookie baking. With a mother and a MIL that make about 20 different kinds between them, we get our fair share of cookies but I want to start my own traditions with my children. This is a great place to start for ideas. I can’t wait until FishMama reveals her recipes!!

  21. Suzanne R says:

    Jessica –
    I always worry about freezing a baked cookie. Do they taste the same when they thaw? I’m tired of marathon baking 2 days before Christmas so everything’s “fresh”.

  22. Love this idea! Giving it a try this season!!

  23. I’m planning for Christmas and came across your blog. Oh man! I love all your ideas, especially this one. Several years ago I spent a day baking different kinds of cookies to give away. I’m not doing that again, not that it wasn’t fun I was just exhausted because I was working a lot of overtime. This is such a smart way to have a variety.

Thanks so much for participating in this conversation about "a mom's life."

This is a place where moms can be themselves. Remember that each mother's path looks a little different. Please keep your comments respectful and kind. Reasonable minds will disagree in a nice way.

So let's talk about it, using "our big girl words."

Share Your Thoughts

*