What’s Your Favorite Christmas Music Album?

We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon.com and affiliated sites. We participate in other affiliate programs as well. For more details, please see our disclosure policy.

Do you have a huge collection of Christmas albums? We don’t. Even though FishPapa is a musician, that’s an area of our music library that is fairly thin.

But the albums that we do have contain music that we absolutely love. Behold the Lamb of God by Andrew Peterson is at the top of the list. I never tire of listening to the story of Jesus — from Creation to Revelation.

What’s YOUR favorite Christmas album?

About Jessica Fisher

I believe you can get great meals on the table -- and still keep that pretty smile on your face.

Read Newer Post
Read Older Post


  1. My favorite is Elvis’s Blue Christmas.

  2. Michelle K says

    Oh Yes! We have lots. Actually, it’s my tradition to buy a new Christmas CD each year. My favorites are “David Foster Christmas Special” and Kenny Rogers “Christmas in America” and Mercy Me (I forget the name of the CD). Faith Hill also has a great one. Our church published a CD this year, so that’s the one we’re getting for 2010.

  3. charlotte says

    I have a collection of old records that I grew up listening to and now I play them for my family. My Dad owned a Service station in the 60 and 70 so they were put out by Good Year of all things. There are songs by Andy Williams, Barbra Streisand, Jonny Mathis, Bing Crosby, New Christy Minstrels, Percy Faith, and many more. I simply love these records they are the sounds of Christmas for me. I also like the Amy Grant Christmas Albums.

  4. David Phelps Joy, Joy

  5. LOVE Point of Grace’s A Christmas Story melts my butter.

  6. We love the CD by Avalon called “Joy.” A good mix of classic Christmas songs plus some touching songs about Jesus.

  7. Casting Crowns!!! Amazing!

  8. Gretchen says

    Charlie Brown Christmas. Hands down classic.

  9. Pretty sure my favorite will always be Amy Grant’s first Christmas album – “A Christmas Album.” Around here it isn’t really the Christmas season until that one has been played.

  10. Elizabeth R says

    We have about 10 or so and Andrew’s is our favorite as well!!! It’s a must have! One of my favorite songs from the album is “Labor of Love.” I love how real it is.

  11. We have tons of Christmas music, or I should say I have tons of christmas music:) I always buy a couple new ones every year. My current favorite is David Phelp’s live Christmas CD, forget the name. I also love Mercy Me’s Christmas CD. Actually I could go on and on with the ones I love, but those are at the top of the list.

  12. Christine says

    I love Point of Grace, A Christmas Story….BUT I am soooo excited to go to the Andrew Peterson Behold the Lamb of God concert on Saturday and plan on buying the CD there. He has always been one of my favorites but never new he had a Christmas CD until you posted it last time. Thanks 🙂

  13. I have a CD entitled Peaceful Christmas that I got years ago that continues to be my favorite year after year. However, I’ve gotten rather attached to my Christmas Playlist online at playlist.com! I have several “lists” there that I use throughout the year, but the Christmas one is by far my favorite!

  14. My fav is Harry Connick Jr.’s Christmas album, we LOVE it!

  15. I’m loving Chris Tomlin’s new album. Amy Grant’s old one is one of my all time favorties. I love every song on it. But I also love Johnny Mathis, Andy Williams, and such. The very first Christmas album (8-track) my husband and I bought was Elvis’ Blue Christmas in 1980. Those songs bring back such memories!

  16. Nat King Cole. It just isn’t Christmas until we hear him sing O Holy Night and The Christmas Song.

  17. We have only a small collection of Christmas cds. My favorite 2 are: A very Ally Christmas by Vonda Shepard and Joy by Jewel!

  18. I love Martina McBride’s White Christmas. Growing up, my dad always played Gene Autrey’s Christmas CD. I still play it for my kids and we love it!

  19. I try to buy a new Christmas CD every year, so it’s great to see some that I’ve been looking at on here. 🙂 One of our favorites is by the Go Fish Guys, SNOW. It’s awesome. I also love many of the ones already mentioned.

    If any of you are looking for good Christian preschool music, check out Go Fish Guys. My kids loved it when they were younger. Lots of great teaching in there!

  20. Betsy M says

    Shawn Colvins, Holiday Songs and Lulabye’s is the BEST Christmas CD. I am tempted to play it throughout the year whenever I am in the kitchen and it has been a hectic day. It is also a wonderful gift for a new mamma around this time of year.

  21. We love the CD “Come Let Us Adore Him” by Haven Ministries. This as a narative between the songs and goes through the Christmas story. Excellent and highly recommended by this family!

  22. I love Sarah Maclachlan’s (sp?) Wintersong. Very lovely voice!

  23. One of my favorites is Selah’s Christmas CD.

  24. Allison says

    I love “The Glory of Christmas” from http://www.majestymusic.com

Thanks so much for participating in this conversation about "a mom's life."

This is a place where moms can be themselves. Remember that each mother's path looks a little different. Please keep your comments respectful and kind. Reasonable minds will disagree in a nice way.

So let's talk about it, using "our big girl words."

Share Your Thoughts