Jesus Cookies for Easter (Recipe: Cinnamon Sugar Cookies)

We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to and affiliated sites. We participate in other affiliate programs as well. For more details, please see our disclosure policy.

We started a new tradition this year. It’s one that I’ve been wanting to do for years. But, somehow, something always got in the way. This year, I seized the day.

We baked and decorated Jesus Cookies for Easter.

In Christmases Past, at least the last 12 of them, we’ve baked Jesus Cookies in December, including cookie cut-outs of the entire manger scene: Mary, Joseph, the Baby in the manger, the wise men, the camels, the donkey, the lamb, the star. You get the picture.

Years ago, I pined away for a similar set of cookie cutters that would represent the events Jesus’ life and of Holy Week. Of course, I never found a set like that. So, this year I made my own.

I dug through our vast cookie cutter collection and pulled out the things that we already had: a praying man (aka Joseph at Christmas), a donkey, a lamb, a sailboat, a fish, a hand, a music note, and letters that spelled out “Jesus” and “God with Us.” I also purchased a few new ones: a cross, a goblet, a crown, and a foot.

Here’s how the symbols break down:

  • letters spelling out: Jesus, God with us
  • a sailboat – He controls the wind and the sea
  • a hand and foot – The Servant king washing the feet of others, as well as the crucifixion
  • a donkey – for His triumphal entry
  • a tree – for Zaccheus, as well as to go with The Tale of Three Trees
  • a praying man – for the mount of olives
  • a lamb – Jesus is our sacrifice
  • a music note – even the stones would praise him
  • a dove – He is the prince of peace
  • a goblet – for the last supper
  • a crown – He is the king of kings

Today the kids and I baked the cookies using a Cinnamon Sugar Cookie recipe. At one point I turned over the rolling and cutting to them. I was amazed at how well they did. It started out with just me girl while the younger one napped. Then the boys joined in, too.

After the cookies were baked and cooled, we decorated them with a simple powdered sugar icing and sprinkles. The kids had such a great time! Why don’t I do this more often?

It’s definitely an Easter activity that we’ll be repeating next year.

The cookie recipe itself is light on the sugar to offset the amount of sugar you may or may not be dumping on top. If you choose not to ice them, simply sprinkle with cinnamon sugar before baking.

Ultimate Recipe Swap

URS Guidelines

Remember: Each week at Ultimate Recipe Swap, there is a posted theme. You are welcome to share any recipe that fits the theme and contains a link back to Life as MOM. If you’re curious about the upcoming themes, I have a calendar here. Last week was Breakfast, this week features Easter and/or Passover; next week we’ll be talking Beef.

If you have a recipe that fits the theme, please link it. However, things like Beef Strogonaff will be deleted from Chicken week because it doesn’t contain chicken. Please keep this meme as helpful to others as we can.

And don’t make me the bad guy! ;)

What’s your favorite recipe for Easter or Passover?


About Jessica Fisher

I believe you can get great meals on the table -- and still keep that pretty smile on your face.

Read Newer Post
Read Older Post


  1. I shared a post on growing my Easter centerpiece. I will update a photo today to show it’s progress. Thanks so much for hosting and have a wonderful day 🙂

  2. Thanks for hosting! Shared a ton of our favorites and some from around the web. Happy and Blessed Easter to you.

  3. This is my first time sharing here! Loving all of these themed recipes!

    Happy Easter

  4. Love this! Where did you get your cookie cutters? And how do you store them? I’ve always avoided them (because they seem to just “waste space” in my drawer), but I’d love to have a specific purpose for them.

    • Jessica Fisher says:

      I have collected cookie cutters over the years. I prefer the Wilton coated metal ones. You can order individual cutters on Amazon, too. I have a plastic box that I store them in and stash on a shelf in the garage so they aren’t in the way.

  5. I love the idea of Jesus cookies!! The cinnamon sugar cookies also sound delicious…I would have never thought to make a sugar cookie cinnamoney 🙂

    • Jessica Fisher says:

      Me neither. But, it works well, especially if you sprinkle with cinnamon sugar before baking.

Thanks so much for participating in this conversation about "a mom's life."

This is a place where moms can be themselves. Remember that each mother's path looks a little different. Please keep your comments respectful and kind. Reasonable minds will disagree in a nice way.

So let's talk about it, using "our big girl words."

Share Your Thoughts